Monday, 18 February 2013

Watching Over Palestine

Ariella Azoulay’s appropriated photograph of the Palestinian town of Kufr Bir’im, loaned to her by second generation refugeee Nahida Zahra

"This photograph of Kufr Bir'im was taken about one month after the state of Israel was established. But this wasn't the first aerial photograph Jews had taken of Arab villages. A Jewish 'air service' had been operating in Palestine's skies since 1947 and contributed to the systematic generation of intelligence on the Arabs. It could do so because the British Mandate did not demand a monopoly of the skies. The lives of the people who've just finished harvesting their grain and bringing it to the threshing floor aren't visible in this bird's-eye view. Instead we see the environment of people's lives in military terms - access roads, emplacements, escape routes, firing positions, etc. [...]" 1

In Ariella Azoulay's appropriated photograph of the Palestinian town of Kufr Bir'im, loaned to her by Nahida Zahra, a second-generation refugee, she provides the above caption as a counter to the official Israeli version of events. The landscape appears pock-marked with open, circular spaces to the right of the city centre, where stacks of white cubes are interconnected and seemingly built one upon another. A line snakes around the perimeter, demarcating the space between Kufr Bir'im and the surrounding hills, intermittent trees, fields differentiated only by the subtle shades of grey in this black-and-white photograph. In the image, the inhabitants of the village are invisible, and intended to remain that way. One need not - should not - think of the people occupying these spaces. Everyday human life is abstracted into a series of blocks, passageways, and potential targets.

This isn't accidental. The detachment of the soldier from his victims is paramount in encouraging them to take action as well as to deal with its consequences. As Dave Grossman has noted, in his book On Killing, the closer the proximity of the soldier to conflict, the stronger the effect on his (un) willingness to pull the trigger. In his analysis of distance of target against general capability to kill, the bomber, along with the artillery crew, represents the maximum range,

"defined as a range where the killer is unable to perceive his individual victims without using some form of mechanical assistance - binoculars, radar, periscope, or remote TV camera." 2

Grossman states:

"Bombing deaths are buffered by the all-important factor of distance. They represent an impersonal act of war in which specific deaths are unintended and almost accidental. ('Collateral damage' is the military euphemism for such killing of civilians while bombing military targets.) Execution of innocent civilians (...) is on the other hand a highly personal act of psychotic irrationality that openly refutes the humanity of the victims. So what is the difference? Ultimately, the difference is distance." 3

This detachment through distance is more recently visible in the increasing prevalence of drone missions where pilots are physically absent from the cockpit, moving and manipulating their vehicles from remote locations (such as C.I.A. headquarters in Langley, Virginia or Creech Air Force Base in Nevada). Similarly, the diminishment of a temporal delay between the locating of a target and subsequent attack might also be seen as an attempt to bypass individual deliberation, as

"[drones] provide an near-instantaneous responsiveness - dramatically shrinking what U.S. military targeting experts call the 'find-fix-finish' loop - that most other platforms lack." 4

Time to think, to consider one's actions, is diminished.

While Azoulay is careful to specify the exact circumstances of this image - the evacuation of Kufr Bir'im's inhabitants and deliberate erasure of its architecture - the aerial military photograph is loaded with insinuations, and expectations, of overhead assault. The surveillance plane is a precursor to the bomber, relaying the preliminary information required to assess and determine possible targets while, at the same time, capturing only the formal, surface qualities of the cityscape. The photograph implies an objectification and dehumanisation of the inhabitants below, akin to the linguistic terminology that Grossman rightly identifies, where 'signature strikes' refer to attacks on individuals or groups who meet certain, unspecified definitions of enemy combatants and 'bug splat', rather than 'collateral damage', stands for unintended civilian casualties. These euphemisms act as a corollary to aerial bombardment, a mode of distancing and abstracting the reality below.

Azoulay's text cuts through the strategic interpretation of the photograph, ensuring that the full consequences and moral implications of Israeli actions are embedded within the image. Her caption continues:

"The Arab Israeli citizens who were expelled from the village still live nearby today. Had the rights stemming from Israeli citizenship not been applied differentially to different sectors of the population, they would long ago have obtained redress and compensation.

This contextualisation doesn't necessarily offer that, but it does close in on whom exactly lives within the image.

Chris Clarke (critic and curator, Lewis Glucksman Gallery, University College Cork)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1.         Ariella Azoulay, From Palestine to Israel: A Photographic Record of Destruction and State Formation, 1947-1950, (London: Pluto Press, 2011), p. 249
2.         Lt. Col. Dave Grossman, On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society, (New York: Back Bay Books, 2009), p. 107
3.         ibid. p. 106
4.         Micah Zenko, Reforming U.S. Drone Strike Policies, (New York: Council on Foreign Relations, 2013), p. 6. http://www.cfr.org/wars-and-warfare/reforming-us-drone-strike-policies/p29736?co=C009601

32 comments:

  1. In his analysis of distance of target against general capability to kill, the bomber, along with the artillery crew, represents the maximum range, geometry dash game

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Right? I actually despise those who minimize the struggles of the individual. It's such a selfish way of managing the problems that we face on our own, without the assistance of a team of people...
    AoneAssignment

    ReplyDelete
  4. A lot of people ask around how they can send authentication messages like OTPs or verification codes whenever someone registers an account on their website or application. The simple answer is that they need to connect their application with an SMS provider using an SMS API.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You can completely acquire proof and hand it over to cops. There would be chain of authority issues of changing degrees relying upon the sort proof 24HWriteMyEssay, yet this is something PI's do frequently. For this situation it would be utilized for the protection which have considerably more breathing space in such manner.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The fringes aren't formally set, and Do My Homework Free numerous regions guaranteed by Palestinians have been involved by Israelis for a considerable length of time. In excess of 135 United Nations part nations perceive Palestine as a free state.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is so amazing article specially the part on which you mentioned new & kind ideas to help & co ordinate with others. the new way to look the life you have mentioned online posting. http://www.milamhealth.com/vision-rx20-review/

    ReplyDelete
  8. The 192.168.l.254 IP address often used by routers as their default gateway, is a private internet protocol address, allows users to gain access to the router’s control panel.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Every single student is searching for a proper essay generator who can understand the need of the work and do the essay completely flawless. However, it often happens that students fail to figure out who can be one of the best instant essay typer for their work.
    Academic essay writing has been a parameter to judge the merits of the students for a long time. The present time is none the less. In fact, as time is passing by, students are having more and more requirements to write an essay that will be graded. Hence seeking Do my essay help is on the rise and it will be.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is the main reason why most students search for online assignment help Australia over the internet and choose only the most proficient and trusted academic writing experts. Law assignment help Australia in understanding how legal theories and concepts can be enforced in the real world. Assignments in the subject of engineering could vary from a dissertation to an essay. This is where engineering assignment help comes into picture. You can see the way that our assignment help Pakistan experts write an answer and learn how we will help you in writing your assignment solution.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for sharing such a cool post. It will interesting to learn for
    Childcare Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  12. Get assistance in assignment, essay and dissertation from the experts of student life saviour at reasonable rates

    ReplyDelete
  13. Australian Assignment Help delivers best quality marketing assignment help in Australia at reasonable rates to its students.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hire a professional writer who has to gives best quality work help to the student. We have many experts writers. who are serving to the student by its best writing service. Our expert writers are online 24*7 hours for essay help uae.

    ReplyDelete
  15. All users of the Smartphone get a good improvement in their lifestyle, well here we are about to talk only with the technical side of Smart Phone usages. Best Messaging Apps

    Kohls Credit Card Login: Prepaid cards and Credit cards have now become an inevitable part of our day to day life. kohls credit card login

    A lot of health and fitness experts highly recommend purchasing ergonomic recliners that have appropriate depth and height, proper body support, and firm cushioning. ergonomic recliner

    I am going to share the complete information about. uncgenie

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Allassignmenthelp provides online Assignment help services to students across the world by its top class professionals with highly effective data.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I love all the posts, I really enjoyed, I would like more information about this, because it is very nice., Thanks for sharing.

    bloxorz

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here
    fireboy and watergirl

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for all your information, Website is very nice and informative content
    bonk.io

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thank you for the information, may be useful for all people of course who read this article
    run 3

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for the information you shared.
    bonk.io

    ReplyDelete

  24. There are lots of assignment writing services and a lot of assignment service agencies in the UK. But students assignment help is the best in all. It offers the world's best my assignment help UK service to the students of the UK.

    ReplyDelete
  25. https://prepaidcardstatus.live/
    http://walgreenslistens.online/

    ReplyDelete
  26. At my assignment help, the students can get support on any analysis assignment topics. Before writing these assignments, the students must develop an in-depth knowledge on the subject which they are going to analyze.

    But in most of the situations, the students do not know how to do my assignment and also do not have firm knowledge about the book, film or novel which they are going to evaluate and end up preparing a paper below the expectations of their professors.

    These essays require logical reasoning, objective writing and a personal touch. The PhD qualified assignment help experts at Essayassignmenthelp.com.au can prepare the papers just according to the need and requirements.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your thoughts are very deep, I feel it has many meanings and humanities
    pogo games

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hey, Your blog is very informative. It is nice to read such high-quality content.For assignment help go for myassignmenthelp.com. For more information related to do my arts architecture assignment.

    ReplyDelete